Traditional firms charge $3,000–$15,000 and take 4–8 weeks. DIY tools charge $300–$600 but you do the classification work yourself. We deliver a complete, done-for-you engineering study at DIY prices — same IRS methodology, same cost databases, 40+ page CPA-ready report — in under an hour. See our full methodology.
A non-DIY cost segregation study is one where the investor receives a completed, CPA-ready report without performing the classification analysis themselves. Modern remote providers deliver these studies using the same IRS methodology as traditional firms, but without site visits or multi-week timelines.
Cost segregation is an engineering-based analysis. The IRS doesn't care whether a human or a machine does the engineering — it cares whether the study follows the methodology described in its Cost Segregation Audit Techniques Guide and contains the 13 principal elements the Guide requires.
The IRS methodology is identical whether the study is done by software or by a team of engineers on-site. The ATG specifies what a study must contain — engineering-based cost approach, component classification, reconciliation to basis, methodology documentation — but not how the analysis is performed. Both approaches use the same cost databases, the same MACRS classification system, and the same IRS audit standards.
Some properties require information that remote data sources can't fully capture. Tenant improvements in a leased commercial space, unusual construction methods in historic buildings, and interior build-outs that aren't reflected in assessor records may need owner-provided documentation or, in rare cases, a physical inspection. For properties over $15M with complex build-outs, a traditional engineering firm with on-site capability may be the better fit.
This is a methodology comparison, not a vendor comparison. For a vendor-specific breakdown (Cost Seg Smart vs KBKG vs traditional firms), see our full provider comparison.
| Traditional Engineering Firm | Automated (Cost Seg Smart) | |
|---|---|---|
| Process | Site visit → manual analysis → report | Order online → software analysis → report |
| Timeline | 4–8 weeks | Under 1 hour |
| Price (residential) | $3,000–$8,000 | $495–$1,295 |
| Price (commercial) | $5,000–$15,000 | $995–$2,995 |
| Data sources | On-site inspection + cost databases | Assessor records + satellite imagery + cost databases |
| Components analyzed | 30–50+ | 200+ |
| IRS methodology | ATG-compliant | ATG-compliant |
| Cost estimation basis | RSMeans / Marshall & Swift | RSMeans 2024 + BLS PPI adjustment |
| Report length | 15–25 pages | 40+ pages |
| MACRS citations | Yes (Rev. Proc. 87-56) | Yes (Rev. Proc. 87-56) |
| Audit documentation | Varies by firm | Included (standard) |
| Site visit required | Yes | No |
| Phone call required | Usually (consultation) | No |
| Best for | Complex commercial ($15M+), unique construction, historic buildings | Residential, STR, multifamily, standard commercial |
We built automated cost segregation because most properties don't need a $5,000+ study with a 6-week timeline. But some do. Here's when a traditional engineering firm is the better choice:
For everything else — single-family rentals, Airbnbs, duplexes, standard multifamily, office buildings, retail, restaurants — the data sources available remotely (assessor records, satellite and aerial imagery, construction cost databases, building permits) capture everything a site visit would. The engineering methodology is identical. The difference is overhead, not quality. For a deeper breakdown of what drives cost segregation pricing, see our independent pricing guide.
Airbnb cost segregation guide →
The positioning is simple.
DIY software is fast but inaccurate — it estimates, it doesn't engineer. Traditional firms are accurate but slow and expensive. We're both: engineering-grade accuracy at software speed. Same IRS methodology. Same component-level analysis. Under an hour instead of under two months.
There's an important distinction between online cost segregation calculators (including ours and our Excel template) and an actual engineering-based cost segregation study. They serve different purposes.
| Online Calculator / Spreadsheet | Engineering-Based Study | |
|---|---|---|
| What it does | Estimates savings using category averages | Analyzes 200+ individual components |
| Accuracy | Directional (±15-20%) | Property-specific (reconciled to basis) |
| Data sources | Property type + purchase price only | Assessor records + satellite + cost DBs + PPI |
| Audit defense | None — not a study | Full documentation, MACRS citations, methodology narrative |
| CPA can file? | No — planning tool only | Yes — Form 4562 / Form 3115 ready |
| Purpose | Decide whether to pursue cost seg | Get the actual numbers your CPA needs |
Online tools — including ours — are useful for deciding whether cost segregation is worth pursuing. But they typically underestimate the actual savings because they use category averages instead of property-specific component analysis. The full study almost always finds more reclassifiable value.
Our approach combines both: a free instant estimate so you can see the ballpark, plus a full engineering study delivered in under an hour for the actual tax-filing numbers. No other provider gives you both.
Address, property type, purchase price, square footage, year built. Upload your closing statement.
Our engine pulls county assessor records, satellite imagery, and building characteristic data automatically.
200+ building components are identified and classified into the correct MACRS recovery period using RSMeans cost data.
A 40+ page PDF with full depreciation schedules, component breakdown, and audit defense documentation. Emailed to you.
The entire process takes under an hour for most properties. No site visit. No phone call. No scheduling. Your CPA receives a report that contains everything they need to file — see what CPAs receive.
Every study produces a 40+ page engineering report that includes:
View a sample report to see exactly what your CPA receives. Or browse 50+ detailed study examples by property type and price point.
Yes. The IRS Cost Segregation Audit Techniques Guide specifies what a study must contain (engineering-based cost approach, component classification, reconciliation to basis, methodology documentation) — not how the analysis is performed. Our software follows the same ATG methodology and produces reports with the same 13 principal elements that IRS examiners check. Read our full audit risk analysis.
The software uses multiple data sources: county assessor records (property characteristics, building details, tax assessment), satellite and aerial imagery (roof type, landscaping, driveways, outbuildings), construction cost databases (RSMeans 2024 component costs adjusted for geography and year built), and building permit records where available. For furnished STRs, the owner provides details about furnishings and upgrades. These sources capture the same building information a site visit would — for standard residential and commercial construction.
RSMeans 2024 construction cost data (the same database most traditional firms use), Bureau of Labor Statistics Producer Price Index for time-based cost adjustment, county assessor records for property characteristics and tax assessment, satellite and aerial imagery for exterior features and site improvements, and geographic cost multipliers for 300+ metro areas. The cost approach is engineering-based and calibrated monthly against actual study results.
Yes. The report includes everything a CPA needs: MACRS depreciation schedules by recovery period, component-level classification with Rev. Proc. 87-56 citations, reconciliation to total cost basis, and Form 3115 documentation for lookback studies. CPAs file our reports the same way they'd file a report from a traditional firm. We include a CPA-Ready Guarantee: if your CPA can't use the report, we'll revise it or refund it. See what CPAs need to know.
Our engine models 200+ individual building components — more than most traditional studies identify on-site. That said, every property is unique. If your property has significant renovations, unusual construction, or components that aren't reflected in assessor records, you can note them during the order process. We also include the CPA-Ready Guarantee: if the report is missing something your CPA needs, we'll revise it at no cost.
Next Steps